Outpush vs. Rollerads: A Comprehensive Comparison to Help You Make the Right Choice

Author :

React :

Comment

If you want to monetize your push notification subscribers over the long term without damaging your reputation, choose Outpush.

RollerAds brings in money faster, but with a lower-quality traffic which could lead to people unsubscribing. I tested both ad networks, and here’s my honest feedback.

The principle of push notifications It's simple: you import followers from a computer or a mobile, and then you can send them a notification directly on their device.

It's a great channel for drive traffic to your website with each new post, but also for generate additional revenue thanks to agencies such as Outpush and RollerAds, which send advertising notifications to your subscriber base.

There are other ad networks on the market that I haven't tried yet. Few people have encouraged me to test them, even though many people use them Outpush on a daily basis.

That's a pretty good sign that the solution is reliable. I've included the affiliate links in the article. I'll tell you what I think, and then it's up to you to make your own choice.

To test Outpush

To test RollerAds

P.S.: I had already provided a full review in the article My opinion of Outpush.

Outpush vs. RollerAds: Who Wins?

Outpush website homepage.
Outpush website homepage. ©Antonin for Alucare.fr

It depends on what you want to build. For a clean site such as alucare.fr, Outpush benefit: you maintain a healthy push notification subscriber base and stable income.

For a short-lived website, RollerAds It pays off faster, but at the expense of your reputation.

Here's what each platform offers you, in practical terms:

  • Outpush : some own notifications sent to your audience. The revenue is lower, but you avoid the fraudulent ads and you'll reduce the number of unsubscribes.
  • RollerAds : higher earnings, but your subscribers receive scam alerts such as «You won XXX$.» Behind that are tunnels used to retrieve a E-mail or have someone sign up for a subscription billed a few days later.

You can block certain ad networks and ads on RollerAds, but it's done by hand, so it takes a while time and it reduces your earnings in the process.

In practice, two site profiles emerge:

  • The «clean» site built to last: Do you want to maintain a push notification subscriber base of quality, don't upset your subscribers and avoid any penalties. In that case, you take Outpush.
  • The «spam» site that drives traffic to a short duration (a few months at most) and needs to be fully monetized. At this point, RollerAds is the aggressive choice.

Just a personal hunch, not a certainty: I'm working on the assumption that Google tracks subscriptions and unsubscriptions. With RollerAds, your foundation is being put to the test.

More unsubscribes may indicate poor-quality notifications, which means the site is seen as less reliable by search engines. I'd rather not take that risk.

For my part, I am returned to Outpush after just 3 and a half days test on RollerAds.

The notifications were so bad that people tagged me on Twitter wondering why I was trying to scam them. That makes sense: the site's name shows up in the notification.

I've included a link to one of these tags further down in the article.

To test Outpush

To test RollerAds

Comparison between Outpush and RollerAds

Home page of the rollerads website.
Rollerads website homepage. ©Antonin for Alucare.fr

Number of notifications sent

The volume of push notifications is not the same across the two platforms, and that’s the first thing to look at: it directly affects the health of your subscriber base.

  • Outpush : 3 to 6 notifications per day (You can contact him to ask for a lower price.).
  • RollerAds : a notification every 20 minutes, or 3 at a time over the course of an hour. You can write to your affiliate manager to reduce the frequency.

The more notifications you send, the more likely you are to lose subscribers. A subscriber who doesn't open your emails is automatically unsubscribed by the system.

After receiving so many notifications, the user gets fed up and eventually blocks them.

Quality of Notifications Sent

The quality of the listings tells you two things: first, whether you're going to make money, and second, whether you're going to get into trouble with misleading advertisements. Simply put, the more you're paid, the more risks you take.

  • Outpush : works with Criteo, Equativ, adYoulike and Taboola. The platform is closed to individual advertisers, so there are no live campaigns. The result: notifications legitimate, no scams. The ad formats used are still traditional display ads, without aggressive targeting.
  • RollerAds : a network open to direct advertisers, which allows for more aggressive campaigns with broad targeting. In practice, your subscribers receive ads like «phone for 1€» or «you’ve won XXX€.» Many’suspicious ads, which are difficult to filter out completely.

On Outpush, I've been here since 1½ years No problem at all. People sometimes ask me why there are notifications Taboola, but no one is unhappy.

On RollerAds, in 3 and a half days, I was tagged on Twitter by people who thought I was trying to help them win 300,000$.

Tweet where I'm tagged for scamming

Retrieving the Subscriber Database

You can retrieve your subscriber base to switch ad networks whenever you want, but the two networks don't handle this the same way.

  • Outpush : helps you set up and restore your database in a way that clean.
  • RollerAds : retrieves subscribers without asking for permission to your previous agency, and does not offer to transfer your client base to another agency if you leave.

In just 3 and a half days on RollerAdsI lost 40,000 subscribers that I can't seem to get back. That base used to bring me 10€ per day and represented 50% of my income push (out of a total of 330,000 subscribers).

A week later, I tried a technique to see if I could recover it, but recovery at 100% is still impossible, and it takes a long time.

Winnings

This is the point that interests most people. Here’s what each platform reports:

  • Outpush : earnings rather low, but they increase as your user base grows. Even if your site goes down, revenue remains stable for about a month and then gradually declines.
  • RollerAds : earnings high, but they don't last. And the loss of active subscribers quickly eats away at your earnings.

To give you a concrete idea: I went from €20 to €50 per day with RollerAds, with 203€ in my account in 3 and a half days.

But on the other hand, I lost 40,000 active subscribers that I can no longer restore. In the long run, I'm the one who loses out.

Payment

Each network has its own system for paying you:

  • Outpush : automatic monthly payment as soon as you exceed 5€. The platform is based in Belgium, so there's no VAT if you're outside Belgium. Several payment methods are available for publishers.
  • RollerAds : automatic or manual payment once a certain threshold is reached (around 500$ (based on my experience), by bank transfer (the only option I've tried).

My personal choice after trying both: Outpush, without hesitation. I’d rather maintain a project that’s viable in the long run than burn through my subscriber base for a few days of high earnings.

To test Outpush

To test RollerAds

👍Your opinion
The article is informative
The article is objective
The article answers my question
Content up to date
🔍 Found any errors? Tell us where!

Found this helpful? Share it with a friend!

This content is originally in French (See the editor just below.). It has been translated and proofread in various languages using Deepl and/or the Google Translate API to offer help in as many countries as possible. This translation costs us several thousand euros a month. If it's not 100% perfect, please leave a comment for us to fix. If you're interested in proofreading and improving the quality of translated articles, don't hesitate to send us an e-mail via the contact form!
We appreciate your feedback to improve our content. If you would like to suggest improvements, please use our contact form or leave a comment below. Your feedback always help us to improve the quality of our website Alucare.fr


Alucare is an free independent media. Support us by adding us to your Google News favorites:

Post a comment on the discussion forum